At many workplaces, Google being a good example, software developers are all called engineers. Web developers are called web engineers, mobile developers are called mobile engineers, and game developers are called game engineers.
To many, engineer is just a job title and doesn't actually mean your job is any different than a developers.
However, I think some distinction is in order because the concept of a web engineer or any software engineer for that matter is useful.
Basically I view a web or software engineer as someone that has more experience than a web developer, but that's not the full story.
A web engineer is someone that has a greater ability to predict the way software will behave.
I also think that a web engineer can be a web developer, but a web developer may not necessarily be a web engineer.
That's because a web engineer is someone with a higher level of skill and therefore predictive power. Similar to the difference between a mechanic and a mechanical engineer a web developer can use the tools that the web engineer built.
A web engineer should be proficient in pattern design, automated testing, and fault-tolerant systems.
Below is how the University of Waterloo describes their Computer Science and Software Engineering degrees. This is useful because it's an actual authority using the term software engineering and they give a good description of what it is.
So a software engineer is someone that focuses less on the abstract and more on the practical. They're engineers and as such they should be able to build software through less trial and error and more predictably.
In the video the professors shows the a Calvin and Hobbes comic strip to illustrate his point.
It's a funny comic and makes a good point that software developers do typically do a lot of trial and error.
And, for a moment I completely bought the argument that developers cant predict software, until I read another users comment which said,
If anything his argument with the predictive is completely off and show he hasn't worked with engineers and kind of assumes that he knows what they do (but being in academia, he probably doesn't know much). He uses that bridge cartoon as saying since civil engineers don't test bridges by adding more weight until it breaks, that they are predictive. The issue is, guess what, they do. Not with the bridge as a whole, but say we're working on a suspension bridge. Those cables are tested by taking a sample and adding tension until they snap. Do that enough and you have an accurate predictor of their strength and therefore you can measure their impact on the bridge as a whole. Aka, they take a unit, test it, and then use the results to see the total effect on the system. It's no different than software engineering. Engineering is a process. A process of using tools, measurements, tests, and math to build something.
My ex is a mech eng. She's working on a new forging process. The calculations didn't match up with the results the first time. So she took that, altered the simulation and repeated until theory matched reality.
Also, the 99% security vulnerability thing is a lot different. Mechanical engineers build jets, but those are still vulnerable to bullets. 110 years ago, engineers couldn't build skyscrapers in Chicago because the soil was too soft. Buildings aren't fireproof and most aren't even earthquake proof. The fact is, everything engineers build is vulnerable to something. The difference is those disciplines don't have people actively trying to find every weakness. Storms aren't trying to figure out the perfect place to hit a house with lightning to burn it down, but that's the challenge developers face. The fact is, we probably make things more bullet proof then most other engineers because they have a minimum level they have to surpass to be ok. Developers have to think ahead to what could exist in the future to bypass anything.
The next comment goes something along the lines of "that was a beautiful analogy" and I completely agree.
And the fact that software engineers can't predict every security vulnerability is just the same as an engineer not being able to make all buildings earthquake or fireproof.
If they do account for an earthquake they can only do so up to certain limits.
You can have a web developer that goes through far more trial and error and just stumbles his way toward the solution without understanding the underlying architecture.
But, with time and a solid understanding of the fundamentals a mechanic could become a mechanical engineer just like a web developer could become a web engineer.
It's all about their level of skill.
It further enforces the need for the term web engineer. I think it's a completely valid term used in the right context.
And the software industry is still young and I think people will become more inclined to distinguish the two terms in the future.
Considering that the education industry is inclined to distinguish a Computer Science degree from a Software Engineering degree I think we're already heading in that direction.
As time goes on there may even be a certification to be a web or mobile engineer much like there is a certification to be a mechanical engineer.
It is interesting though that many electrical engineers or computer engineers don't need a license to practice engineering.
This is likely because if a computer circuit malfunctions it can be easily tested for and won't cause a huge loss of life. If a civil engineer doesn't do their job correctly then people will die, and therefore it makes more sense for a license to be a requirement.
This seems to indicate that a license requirement for software engineers will never be a requirement into the future, although for more mission critical systems more stringent interview processes are likely.
Web Engineer will likely be a more commonly used word in the future because of it's usefulness, but it's hard to imagine any certification or licenses being required by employers. Because of this, it may be common for quite a while to hear the term web developer or web engineer used the exact same way.
What do you think? Let me know in the comments 😊